PIE LOVER'S WELCOME!

Click on product hyperlink for more details.

Me, Myself & Pies offer savory and sweet pies in three different sizes. A large traditional nine inch pie that yields eight delicious slices. We have a medium six inch pie, which is perfect to share with a friend, or perhaps just indulge by yourself! Lastly, our three inch mini pie is the perfect snack size for your late night cravings, afternoon pick me up, or a deliciously sweet breakfast. Local pick-up ONLY for Saturday online orders must be placed by Tuesday 5pm. We’re at the Fernandina Beach Farmers Market located on N. 7th Street in historic, downtown Fernandina Beach between Alachua and Centre Streets and is open on Saturdays, from 9 a.m. to 1:00 p.m., year round, rain or shine. 

Other days: call us at 904.757.2227 or email us info@memyselfandpies.com closed Sunday and Monday. Please allow a 72 hour window after ordering to pick up a pie at our commercial kitchen in Riverside (1020 Park Street Jacksonville, Fl. 32204). We are an on demand pie catering company with delivery (orders over $75.00 + and delivery fee starting $20.00 + ) and pick-up (orders over $50.00 +) options available by confirmed verbal or email appointment only prior to ordering please.  Please allow a 72 hour turnaround after ordering.

     
    Chocolate Chess Pie w/ strawberry glaze topping 3 in. 6 pack Pumpkin Pie 9 in. Deep Dish Shepherd's/Cottage Pie MMP Exclusive 6in
    Chocolate Chess Pie w/ strawberry glaze topping 3 in. 6 packPumpkin Pie 9 in. Deep DishShepherd's/Cottage Pie MMP Exclusive 6in

    $18.00

    $20.00

    $9.00

    Shepherd's/Cottage Pie MMP Exclusive 9 in. 3 in. Sampler 12 pack Banana Cream Pie 3in 6 pack
    Shepherd's/Cottage Pie MMP Exclusive 9 in.3 in. Sampler 12 packBanana Cream Pie 3in 6 pack

    $25.00

    $39.00

    $18.00

    Banana Cream Pie 6 inch Banana Cream Pie 9 inch Chocolate Chess Pie w/ strawberry glaze topping  6 inch
    Banana Cream Pie 6 inchBanana Cream Pie 9 inchChocolate Chess Pie w/ strawberry glaze topping 6 inch

    $7.25

    $20.00

    $7.25

    Chocolate Chess Pie w/ strawberry glaze topping 9 inch Classic Apple  Pie 3 in. 6 pack Classic Apple Pie 6 in.
    Chocolate Chess Pie w/ strawberry glaze topping 9 inchClassic Apple Pie 3 in. 6 packClassic Apple Pie 6 in.

    $20.00

    $18.00

    $7.25

    Classic Apple Pie 9 in. Seafood Quiche 6 inch Seafood Quiche 9 inch Deep Dish
    Classic Apple Pie 9 in.Seafood Quiche 6 inchSeafood Quiche 9 inch Deep Dish

    $20.00

    $10.00

    $30.00

    Beef Pot Pie 6 inch Beef Pot Pie 9 inch Deep Dish Chicken Pot Pie 6 inch
    Beef Pot Pie 6 inchBeef Pot Pie 9 inch Deep DishChicken Pot Pie 6 inch

    $8.00

    $20.00

    $8.00

    (1)
    Chicken Pot Pie 9 inch Deep Dish Quiche 6 inch Quiche 9 inch Deep Dish
    Chicken Pot Pie 9 inch Deep DishQuiche 6 inchQuiche 9 inch Deep Dish

    $20.00

    $8.00

    $20.00

    3 in Sampler 24 pack 6 in Sampler 3 pack 6 in Sampler 5 pack
    3 in Sampler 24 pack 6 in Sampler 3 pack6 in Sampler 5 pack

    $75.00

    $21.00

    $36.00

    Blueberry Pie 3 in. 6 pack Blueberry Pie 6 in. Blueberry Pie 9 in.
    Blueberry Pie 3 in. 6 pack Blueberry Pie 6 in. Blueberry Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Creamy Buttermilk Pie 3 in. 6 pack Creamy Buttermilk Pie 6 in. Creamy Buttermilk Pie 9 in.
    Creamy Buttermilk Pie 3 in. 6 packCreamy Buttermilk Pie 6 in.Creamy Buttermilk Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Crimson Cherry Pie 3 in. 6 pack Crimson Cherry Pie 6 in. Crimson Cherry Pie 9 in.
    Crimson Cherry Pie 3 in. 6 packCrimson Cherry Pie 6 in. Crimson Cherry Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Chocolate French Silk Pie 3 in. 6 pack Chocolate French Silk Pie 6 in. Chocolate French Silk Pie 9 in.
    Chocolate French Silk Pie 3 in. 6 packChocolate French Silk Pie 6 in.Chocolate French Silk Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Coconut Cream Dream Pie 3 in. 6 pack Coconut Cream Dream Pie 6 in. Coconut Cream Dream Pie 9 in.
    Coconut Cream Dream Pie 3 in. 6 packCoconut Cream Dream Pie 6 in.Coconut Cream Dream Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    (1)

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Key Lime Pie 3 in. 6 pack Key Lime Pie 6 in. Key Lime Pie 9 in.
    Key Lime Pie 3 in. 6 packKey Lime Pie 6 in.Key Lime Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Lemon Meringue Pie 3 in. 6 pack Lemon Meringue Pie 6 in. Lemon Meringue Pie 9 in.
    Lemon Meringue Pie 3 in. 6 pack Lemon Meringue Pie 6 in. Lemon Meringue Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Lemon Supreme Pie 3 in. 6 pack Lemon Supreme Pie 6 in. Lemon Supreme Pie 9 in.
    Lemon Supreme Pie 3 in. 6 packLemon Supreme Pie 6 in.Lemon Supreme Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Mixed Berry Pie 3 in. 6 pack Mixed Berry Pie 6 in. Mixed Berry Pie 9 in.
    Mixed Berry Pie 3 in. 6 packMixed Berry Pie 6 in.Mixed Berry Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Oreo Pie 3 in. 6 pack Oreo Pie 6 in. Oreo Pie 9 in.
    Oreo Pie 3 in. 6 packOreo Pie 6 in.Oreo Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Peach Pie 3 in. 6 pack Peach Pie 6 in. Peach Pie 9 in.
    Peach Pie 3 in. 6 packPeach Pie 6 in.Peach Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Pristine Pecan Pie 3 in. 6 pack Pristine Pecan Pie 6 in. Pristine Pecan Pie 9 in.
    Pristine Pecan Pie 3 in. 6 packPristine Pecan Pie 6 in.Pristine Pecan Pie 9 in.

    $20.00

    $7.50

    $25.00

    Peanut butter Pie 3 in. 6 pack Peanut Butter Pie 6 in Peanut Butter Pie 9 in
    Peanut butter Pie 3 in. 6 pack Peanut Butter Pie 6 inPeanut Butter Pie 9 in

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Snicker's Pie 3 in. 6 pack Snicker's Pie 6 in. Snicker's Pie 9 in.
    Snicker's Pie 3 in. 6 packSnicker's Pie 6 in. Snicker's Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Southern Paradise Southern Paradise Pie 6 in Southern Paradise Pie 9 in
    Southern Paradise Pie 3 in 6 packSouthern Paradise Pie 6 in Southern Paradise Pie 9 in

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Strawberry Pie 3 in. 6 pack Strawberry Pie 6in Strawberry Pie 9 in.
    Strawberry Pie 3 in. 6 packStrawberry Pie 6inStrawberry Pie 9 in.

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Sweet Potato Pie 3 in. 6 pack Sweet Potato Pie 6 in. Sweet Potato Pie 9 in. Deep Dish
    Sweet Potato Pie 3 in. 6 packSweet Potato Pie 6 in.Sweet Potato Pie 9 in. Deep Dish

    $18.00

    $7.25

    $20.00

    Sweet Potato Pie 9 in (Regular)
    Sweet Potato Pie 9 in (Regular)

    $15.00

    Please note: As we do not operate a storefront, local pick-ups are available at The Fernandina Beach Farmers Market located on N. 7th Street in historic, downtown Fernandina Beach between Alachua and Centre Streets and is open on Saturdays, from 9 a.m. to 1:00 p.m., year round, rain or shine.

     

    Other days: call us at 904.757.2227 or email us info@memyselfandpies.com closed Sunday and Monday. Please allow a 72 hour window after ordering to pick up a pie at our commercial kitchen in Riverside (1020 Park Street Jacksonville, Fl. 32204). We are an on demand pie catering company with delivery (orders over $75.00 + and delivery fee starting $20.00 + ) and pick-up (orders over $50.00 +) options available by confirmed verbal or email appointment only prior to ordering please.  Please allow a 72 hour turnaround after ordering.

    Thank you for allowing us to serve you!